The Vitaminwater Lawsuit: Why You Should Always Check The Label!
Following a low-sugar diet is one of the fastest ways to improve your health. Sugar has been linked to inflammation, heart disease, and many other serious conditions, in addition to being a significant cause of gut dysbiosis and Candida overgrowth. However, removing all those added sugars from your diet can be difficult unless you really know how to read those food labels carefully.
You may have read about a recent lawsuit brought against Coca-Cola for the alleged “deceptive labeling and marketing” of their Vitaminwater brand. In fact, a couple of weeks ago a US judge recommended that the lawsuit go to court as a class action.
In today’s post I’m going to take a look at what makes drinks like Vitaminwater so controversial, and what it means for those of us on a low-sugar diet.
The Facts
No-one disputes that Vitaminwater has a high sugar content – it’s written right there on the label. Most of their drinks contain 31-32 grams of sugar (if you’re having trouble visualizing this, that’s 7 teaspoons and almost as much as a can of Coke).
How is the sugar added to Vitaminwater? A more health-conscious manufacturer might include something like fruit juice concentrate to sweeten their drinks. But the sugar content in Vitaminwater comes from two refined sources – cane sugar and crystalline fructose.
Cane sugar is extracted from sugar cane, then refined and dried into crystalline form. It might contain a few extra vitamins and minerals from the cane sugar plant, but it is essentially just refined sucrose. Crystalline fructose is about 98% fructose, and is often used as an alternative to High Fructose Corn Syrup.
The effect of this high sugar content is to make you feel great – for a very short time! Relatively pure sugars like these are absorbed quickly by the body and spike your blood sugar. This gives you a temporary high but soon leaves you craving for more. I’ve mentioned the addictive qualities of sugar before – some studies have found it to be more addictive than cocaine, nicotine or alcohol.
Always Read The Label
‘Crystalline fructose and cane sugar’ are listed as ingredient #2 on the Vitaminwater label. If you’re familiar with labeling practices, you’ll know that the higher an ingredient appears on the label, the more of it the product contains. And often these sugars will be ‘disguised’ under several different names. In this case, sugars are the second largest ingredient in Vitaminwater, besides water itself.
Yet Vitaminwater has consistently been marketed as a healthy alternative to other sodas and soft drinks. Their marketing has included phrases like ‘nutrient-enhanced water beverage’, but should that really read ‘sugar-enhanced water beverage’?
What is Coca-Cola’s defense? You might think that they would pull out all the stops to show how healthy Vitaminwater really is. Well, no… In a recent court briefing, the lawyer representing Coca-Cola claimed that “no consumer could reasonably be misled into thinking Vitaminwater was a healthy beverage.” So despite all the marketing and packaging that implies otherwise, they have acknowledged that Vitaminwater was never designed to be healthy.
Sadly this is not the only example of added sugar being hidden in plain sight. Pasta sauce, ketchup, smoothies, salad dressings, and processed meats are all places where you can find lots of added sugar. The only way to avoid it is to read labels carefully and make informed decisions about which foods to buy.
If you are fighting a Candida overgrowth it is best to avoid all processed drinks. You could have water infused with lemon or lime, herbal teas, and Candida safe smoothies in our recipe section.
For Candida sufferers, following a low-sugar diet is one of the key elements in any good Candida treatment plan. In our Candida treatment program we include shopping lists, comprehensive tables of foods to eat and avoid, and lots of tasty recipes that won’t make your Candida worse.
Beat your candida in 60 days with this detailed 5-step program
If you're looking for a more comprehensive Candida treatment plan, check out the Ultimate Candida Diet program, written by Lisa Richards and Dr Eric Wood. This plan is based on the latest research into Candida Related Complex, and contains everything you need to know to beat your Candida overgrowth.
Does this include Vitamin Water Zero, since it it sweetened with Stevia? Thank you for all your helpful information!
Hi Tawny, great question! This article is about regular Vitaminwater, but they do also have a brand named Vitaminwater Zero that contains Stevia. Here is the nutritional data – http://vitaminwater.com/files/vitaminwater_zero_2014_NutritionFacts.pdf.
Whenever you read that something is ‘naturally sweetened’ or ‘sweetened with Stevia’, you need to see if they have included any other sweeteners in there. In the case of Vitaminwater Zero, it is also sweetened with Erythritol. This is the sugar alcohol that is used in Truvia too, and it is a heavily processed sweetener usually derived from GMO corn. It doesn’t raise your blood sugar, but it doesn’t have all the benefits of Xylitol, which is the best sugar alcohol for Candida sufferers. Another item in the ingredients list is ‘natural flavors’, which can cover all kinds of lab-produced chemical flavorings, as long as they end up chemically equivalent to their natural counterparts.
Overall, I would say that Vitaminwater Zero is not a bad option for Candida sufferers, but it is not the all-natural drink that the marketing would have you believe. It is not ideal but it’s certainly a much better option than regular Vitaminwater!
Was going to ask the same thing! Thanks for the thorough answer! 🙂
Hi Lisa,
I appreciate your article re Vitamin Water and particularly Vitamin Water Zero,
however; your reply to Tawny omits the pertinent fact that Vitamiin Water Zero
also contains crystaline fructose.
Paul
Seriously, why would anyone be lead to believe that vitamin water is healthy? I’m sure this lawyer has a good point.
Anything coming from the Coca-Cola company is meant for enjoyment, not health. Just look at the colour of the drink…
I assume people are also saying Dasani or Smartwater is good water.
Great article. I always considered vitamin water another pathetic attempt at sales versus health. Thank you.
Thanks for all your tips